"I have no idea what's going on!"

You do, but your best bet is to play dumb.

"This is all some big misunderstanding. I paid my tuition just like everyone else!"

Peter doesn't buy it. He starts reading your bill for Fall, 2024.

"Total outstanding dollars owed to Yale College for the Fall Semester, 2024, paid for with $50,246.png," he says.

He reads it again.